My latest craze has been Netbook oriented as I want to find out why a lot of people have started adopting this approach to their daily needs. I started out by trying Google's famed Chromium OS and subsequently visited the Ubuntu solution from Canonical as well. Here's what I found and maybe it can be useful to people that are trying the same.
The setup
Both Chromium and U-Netbook can be installed on a USB stick and just booted up by changing the BIOS options to load the OS from the desired location on boot. I found that Chromium offered the faster experience on load and this might be attributed to the fact that the entire OS is built on the Chrome Browser. The Ubuntu release didn't really take much longer but it did take a whole extra three seconds on my laptop and then finally did load.
The quirks on load
Chromium offered no wireless support for the version I tested and hence I was forced to run my entire experience via a cable connected to my laptop which lead to a rather unpleasant first start. The Ubuntu client however, loaded up and then offered me a list of Wireless networks to choose from. A click of my choice and a WEP PWD enter later I was browsing the internet with no cables at all. The only place where the Chromium OS just put U-NetBook to shame was related to the delay in response from the client when U-NB loaded. My entire notebook froze and I was only able to move the mouse till it loaded something that never really stopped loading through my entire experience.
The User Management and Login
Chromium gave me the universal Google way of handling things which let me into the OS via a simple username and password screen that took my Google account and then offered me all the rest of my Google services at a simple click away as I was logged into the service(s). Ubuntu on the other hand just loaded up and froze for a bit before it offered me all the standard Ubuntu functionality that I have come to expect from my Ubuntu box that I run with a Desktop version of Ubuntu.
Managing the Experience
This is where Chromium dropped the ball and for the most part you can understand why Google have done this. The Chromium browser is your one stop shop into how the entire OS runs and everything is done in a browser window offering applications that are web-based ranging from a calculator all the way to Google Docs and the integrated Google Talk component inside Gmail. Ubuntu offers users the ability to change preferences, install hardware/software and gives any hardened Linux user the standard options they are used to.
First Impressions and Verdict
I am a fan of speed and Chromium OS is the faster of the two. It handled the load quickly, got me into my mail, provided me some standard links to utilities I might need and actually got me running as a standard web-user. Ubuntu Netbook is something a power user who just wants a quick loader for themselves will stick to. It offers enough to leave your slow Windows-based machine and migrate to it without even blinking an eyelid. The speed of the applications was very good and it all just fit on a USB stick offering me a chance to install it locally.
Google Chromium vs Ubuntu Netbook
- Chromium is a great out-of-the-box experience - it offered me browsing (with Flash), widgets for my daily work and the ease of sign-in with my Google ID/PWD
- Ubuntu is great until you get to the home screen and then it just hangs. It didn't come Flash ready and it wasn't until I installed Google Chrome on it that I managed to get my Flash experience back on track. Hardly, something that a person requiring web-access should have to do but some will argue that its a one-time installation and that it shouldn't hamper the experience.
- Chromium is still in Beta and will probably remain that way for a while until Google feels its public ready. The system did hang in certain instances where I wanted it to load specific information that was very heavy but it didn't really hamper my ability to browse pages.
If your a hard-core web fan then Chromium is probably something you'd use to get an average joe introduced to the whole netbook experience. It turns on quick, gets you on even faster and if they can sort out the whole WiFi issue then they will have a winner.
If you are the kind of person that needs all the fancy customizations and everything to look all glossy and pretty with a hand under the hood at all times then Ubuntu Netbook is the way to go. The Ubuntu One sign-in offers great synchronization across all PC's using U-NB and this is also true for Chromium. The Firefox that comes with it needs to be seriously repackaged with some better in-house support, however, with the advent of HTML-5 I don't see that being a real issue.
I hope this helps anyone out there who is looking at a Netbook OS option and I am always willing to hear back from you'll about your experiences and how its worked out for you.
Music Listened to while writing this post - Sound of Silence - Simon and Garfunkel